fbpx

/

What the REAL Health Providers Act Proposed Rule Would Change for Medicare Advantage Provider Directories

Proposed Rule REAL Health Provider Act

New provider directory accuracy requirements for Medicare Advantage (MA) organizations are taking shape. The Centers for Medicare & Medicaid Services (CMS) published proposed rule CMS-4214-P, seeking comments on implementing the Requiring Enhanced and Accurate Lists of (REAL) Health Providers Act. The proposed rule presents potential frameworks, methodologies, and approaches for implementing requirements related to accuracy standards, accuracy score reporting, verification, public transparency, and enrollee cost-sharing protections.

Understanding what CMS is proposing can help you plan your provider data management and compliance efforts before the rule is finalized. Comments are due by 5 p.m. EST on December 15, 2026.

REAL Health Providers Act Requirements at a Glance

Beginning with contract year 2028, the statute requires MA organizations offering specified MA plans to meet these requirements.

  1. 90-day Verification: Verify each listed provider’s directory information at least once every 90 days. Hospitals and other facilities the Secretary selects may be verified less often, but at least once every 12 months.
  2. Handling Unverified Provider Data in the Directories: Include an indicator in the directory when a provider’s information couldn’t be verified and may not be up to date.
  3. 5-Business-Day Removal for Non-Network Providers: Remove a provider within 5 business days of determining the provider is no longer in the plan’s network.
  4. Provider Directory Information: Maintain an accurate public directory with information such as name, specialty, contact information, office or facility addresses, whether the provider is accepting new patients, accommodations for people with disabilities, cultural and linguistic capabilities, and telehealth capabilities.
  5. Annual Accuracy Analysis: Estimate directory accuracy each year using a random sample of the directory information that includes specialty types with high inaccuracy rates, such as mental health or substance use disorder treatment, and report the results and an accuracy score to CMS.
  6. Public Accuracy Scores: Beginning with contract year 2029, display the plan’s accuracy score in its directory, while CMS posts all scores in a machine-readable file on its website.
  7. Enrollee Cost Sharing Protections: Limit cost sharing to in-network levels when an enrollee relies on a directory listing for a provider who turns out to be out of network.

Although the statute uses the term “plan year,” CMS customarily uses “contract year.” Therefore, CMS proposes using “contract year” throughout the proposed regulations, and we’ll do the same in this blog post.

CMS's Approach: Building on Existing Standards

Rather than creating a separate or competing set of standards, CMS intends to build on existing provider directory rules. As the proposed rule states, “…in implementing the REAL Health Providers Act, CMS intends to build directly upon, reinforce, and, where necessary, supplement this existing regulatory infrastructure, ensuring MA organizations have a clear and harmonized set of provider directory requirements, rather than creating a parallel, duplicative, or competing set of standards.”

CMS views this integrated approach as the most administratively sound and least burdensome path forward. By leveraging existing regulatory requirements, working toward a centralized national directory, and incorporating the REAL Health Providers Act’s data accuracy mandates, the agency aims to give beneficiaries access to accurate and reliable provider information.

Here’s how the pieces fit together:

  • Medicare Plan Finder (MPF): The existing data submission framework MA organizations use, which also supports plan comparison.
  • National Provider Directory (NPD): A broader, multi-payer directory accessible to all.
  • REAL Health Providers Act: Accuracy, verification, cost-sharing protections, and public reporting requirements

“What we’re seeing is CMS laying the groundwork for a shared provider data infrastructure, which opens the door for the same verified provider data to be increasingly reused, compared, and relied on across federal programs,” said Kate Deiters, Policy Specialist at Quest Analytics®.

 

Which Plans Would Be Affected

What the statute requires: The requirements apply to “specified MA plans.”

What CMS proposes: Defining “specified MA plan” as any network-based plan, which includes MA plans that are coordinated care plans (for example, health maintenance organizations (HMOs), provider-sponsored organizations, regional or local preferred provider organizations (PPOs), and specialized MA plans for special needs individuals), network-based Medicare Savings Account (MSA) plans, or cost plans—and private fee-for-service (PFFS) plans that meet the access standards under § 422.114, in whole or in part, through entering into contracts or agreements with a network of providers.

The proposed requirements would not apply to non-network regional PPOs and Program of All-Inclusive Care for the Elderly (PACE) plans.

 

Provider Directory Verification Requirements

Proposed Directory Information

What the statute requires: MA organizations must maintain an accurate provider directory on a publicly available website. The statute describes directory information as information enrollees may need to access covered benefits, such as name, specialty, contact information, addresses, whether the provider is accepting new patients, accommodations for people with disabilities, cultural and linguistic capabilities, and telehealth capabilities.

What CMS proposes: Treating the statutory list as required and adding a ninth element, common ownership or control disclosure, which would identify network providers that share ownership or control with the MA organization or its parent organization.

“The ownership disclosure reflects a wider policy interest in vertical integration. Whatever form it takes in a final rule, it suggests regulators see network composition, alongside network accuracy, as information beneficiaries should be able to see,” said Deiters.

Verification Cadence

What the statute requires: MA organizations must verify the provider directory information of each listed provider not less frequently than once every 90 days and, if applicable, update it. Hospitals and other facilities the Secretary determines appropriate may be verified less often, but no less frequently than once every 12 months.

Facilities on a 12-Month Verification Cycle

What CMS proposes: A 12-month verification cycle for the three facilities:

  • Acute inpatient hospitals
  • Critical care services (intensive care units)
  • Surgical services (outpatient or ambulatory surgery center)


CMS selected these three types of entities because CMS believes that data for these specific entities is generally more static, as they may not move locations as often as other providers or facilities given their size and facility requirements. Additionally, MA organizations are already familiar with this list for network adequacy purposes.

Verification Methods

What CMS proposes: For the 90-day or the 12-month cycle, MA organizations would be required to use one or more CMS-specified verification methods to fulfill the obligation.

  • Internal plan information, such as current rosters or recent claims
  • Telephone or email verification
  • Provider attestations
  • Data sources maintained by CMS, such as the National Plan and Provider Enumeration System (NPPES) and eventually the National Provider Directory
  • Claims data
  • Other methods CMS specifies in technical guidance
    • CMS explicitly left room to approve additional methods through technical guidance, citing fast-moving technology and artificial intelligence. The agency also plans to issue best-practice guidance on which methods suit which data elements.

At this time, CMS does not propose to limit which verification methods can be used for routine 90-day and 12-month verification. It does propose limits for accuracy score purposes, covered below.

May Not Be Up To Date Indicator and Directory Listings

What the statute requires: When an MA organization is unable to verify a provider’s information during the applicable verification cycle, the directory must indicate that the information may not be up to date.

What CMS proposes: Using language such as “The provider’s information may not be up to date.” The indicator would be removed or revised once the information is verified or updated.

Provider Contract Requirement

Recognizing that verification includes both plans and providers, CMS is proposing a new provider contract requirement.

What CMS proposes: MA organizations offering a specified MA plan would be required to include a term in their provider contracts obligating the contracted provider to maintain current and accurate provider directory information. The goal is to improve the reliability of data obtained directly from contracted providers. “CMS believes that this proposed provider contract term is necessary to assist MA organizations in carrying out successful verification efforts, which would ultimately support the broader effort to ensure accurate provider directories.”

 

Provider Directory Updating Requirements

5-Business Day Removals and Updates

What the statute requires: MA organizations must remove a provider from the directory within 5 business days after the date on which the MA organization determines that the provider is no longer participating in the network of the specified MA plan.

What CMS proposes: Applying the 5-business-day removal to both the online directory and the PDF or otherwise printable electronic copy of the provider directory. CMS clarified that MA organizations could update the posted PDF or otherwise printable electronic copy of the provider directory on their website within 5 business days, rather than requiring the MA organization to mail revised printed directories on the same timeline.

The current requirement for making all other updates to provider directory data within 30 days remains in place.

Printed Directory Requirements

CMS is using this opportunity to update the requirements related to physical hardcopy provider directories. Below is what CMS is considering:  

  1. Establish a Quarterly Cadence: MA organizations send a quarterly addendum with updates to enrollees who requested a physical hardcopy directory. This would replace the current policy, under which a printed directory with addenda is considered up to date.
  2. Include a Hardcopy Disclaimer: Printed directories would include a disclaimer recommending that readers check the online directory or contact the plan for the latest updates.
  3. Clarification on Marketing Materials: If plans, agents, or brokers choose to distribute physical hardcopy directories, they would be required to print the current PDF from the MA organization’s website. This would help prospective enrollees receive the most recent version available at the time of distribution.

 

How the Proposed Provider Directory Accuracy Score Would Work

What the statute requires: Beginning with contract year 2028, MA organizations must conduct an annual analysis estimating the accuracy of its provider directory information using a random sample of providers included in their provider directory. The sample shall include a random sample of providers from each specialty with high inaccuracy rates relative to other specialties, such as providers specializing in mental health or substance use disorder treatment. Additionally, MA organizations must submit a report with the results and accuracy score to CMS.

What CMS is proposing: An annual accuracy analysis with a defined sampling frame, methodology, and scoring approach. All information in this section is a proposal that could change in the final rule.

Accuracy Analysis and Sampling Methodology

CMS is proposing:
Sample Split: MA organizations could use a random sample, a random sample of directory records for each specified MA plan, 65% drawn from the general directory, and 35% drawn from provider specialty types with high inaccuracy rates.

Plan-level samples, consolidated outreach: Samples would be drawn for each specified MA plan, but CMS intends to require MA organizations to consolidate samples across the organization, so a provider who appears in several plans’ samples would only need to be contacted once per verification method.

High-Inaccuracy Specialties:

The sample must include a random sample of each specialty of providers with a high inaccuracy rates as determined by the Secretary. One type of specialty may be providers specializing in mental health or substance use disorder treatment.

CMS is proposing: Mental health and substance use disorder treatment provider specialty types listed below and identifying these providers using two code sources.

  1. The primary source CMS anticipates using is the Medicare Physician/Non-Physician Practitioner specialty codes identified in section 10.8 of chapter 26 of the Medicare Claims Processing Manual.
  1. CMS also anticipates using additional National Uniform Claim Committee (NUCC) taxonomy codes, where appropriate, to supplement the Medicare specialty codes.

 

Proposed Codes for Mental Health or Substance Use Disorder Treatment Providers

Code
Description
26Psychiatry
27Geriatric Psychiatry
86Neuropsychiatry
62Psychologist
68Clinical Psychologist
80Licensed Clinical Social Worker
79Addiction Medicine
D5Opioid Treatment Program
E1Marriage and Family Therapist
E2Mental Health Counselor
 

NUCC Taxonomy Codes Under Consideration

Code
Description
104100000XBehavioral Health & Social Service Providers/Social Worker
101Y00000XBehavioral Health & Social Service Providers/Counselor
363LP0808XPhysician Assistants & Advanced Practice Nursing Providers / Nurse Practitioner, Psychiatric/Mental Health


CMS intends to publish the specific codes in annual technical guidance. The agency plans to release draft guidance with proposed codes, solicit stakeholder feedback, and then issue final guidance incorporating that input.

Other High-Specialty Inaccuracy Specialties Under Consideration

CMS believes the provider directory accuracy analysis should focus on a blend of provider specialty types and is considering adding primary care providers, cardiologists, and oncologists to the high-inaccuracy list — each had a deficiency rate of 45% or higher in CMS’s June 2022 to June 2024 online directory reviews.

CMS acknowledges that its current data for identifying high-inaccuracy specialties is limited to its own online directory reviews and OIG studies. To build a stronger base for future rulemaking, CMS is considering collecting more data from MA organizations alongside the accuracy score, such as response rates by specialty type and verification method, and supplementing that data with outside research.

Proposed Provider Data Verification Limits, Weights, and Grades

CMS is proposing limiting verification methods and weighting provider directory accuracy scoring methodology, for scoring purposes. The table below shows each directory element, whether it would be verified on the 90-day cycle or the 12-month, whether it would count toward the annual accuracy score, and its proposed weight.

Directory Element
90-Day or 12-Month Verification
Annual Accuracy Score
Proposed Weight for Accuracy Score
Network Participation StatusYesYes40%
Contact Information, including telephone number(s)YesYes20%
Primary Office or Facility Addresses where covered items or services are furnishedYesYes20%
SpecialtyYesYes10%
Accommodations for People with DisabilitiesYesYes3.5%
Telehealth CapabilitiesYesYes3.5%
Accepting New PatientsYesYes3%
Provider NameYesNot scoredNot scored
Cultural and Linguistic CapabilitiesYesNot scoredNot scored
Common Ownership or Control DisclosureYesNot scoredNot scored

 

Proposed Verification Methods for the Accuracy Score

For the accuracy score only, CMS proposes limiting which verification methods could confirm which elements.

Verification Method
Elements It Could Confirm for the Accuracy Score

Internal Plan Information

Network Participation Status, Specialty

Telephone or Email

Specialty, Contact Information, Addresses, Accepting New Patients, Accommodations for People with Disabilities, Telehealth

Provider Attestations

Any Element

Claims Data

Network Participation Status, Specialty

Data Sources Maintained by CMS

None Proposed Yet; Possible Future Option

Proposed Accuracy Score Letter Grade Conversion

CMS is considering converting the accuracy composite score to a letter grade.

Weighted Score
Grade

90% to 100%

A

80% to 89%

B

70% to 79%

C

60% to 69%

D

50% to 59%

E

49% and below

F

Proposed Annual Accuracy Report Requirements

What the statute requires: Beginning on or after contract year 2028, each MA organization must submit to the Secretary a report with the results of the accuracy analysis, including the accuracy score.

What CMS proposes: Plans would submit a report with the accuracy score for each specified MA plan by the first Monday in April following the measured contract year. For contract year 2028, the first report would be due in April 2029.

In addition to this requirement, CMS is exploring several additional reporting elements to help the agency monitor implementation and update its technical guidance. These elements under consideration include:

  1. Provider Specialty Response Rates by Verification Method
  2. Other Sampling Data by Specialty, Possibly Reported by NUCC Taxonomy Code
  3. Estimated Administrative Costs to the MA Organization
  4. Estimated Administrative Costs to Its Contracted Providers
  5. Data On Use of the Cost Sharing Protections


A Note on GAO Coordination:
CMS notes that in considering this list, it is keeping in mind what the U.S. Government Accountability Office (GAO) will be interested in for purposes of its study and report, as required by the REAL Health Providers Act. Specifically, the GAO is required to study the use of cost sharing protections, the trend in provider directory information accuracy scores submitted to CMS – both overall and among providers specializing in mental health or substance use disorder treatment, provider response rates by plan verification methods, administrative costs to providers and MA organizations, and other items determined appropriate.

Independent Third-Party Certification

CMS is considering requiring MA organizations to have their annual provider directory accuracy analysis and score independently reviewed and certified by a qualified third party prior to submission to CMS.

According to CMS, this independent review would serve several purposes: promoting consistency in how plans apply the sampling methodology, building confidence in the reported accuracy scores, and providing an additional safeguard against implementation variations across MA organizations.

This approach mirrors other CMS reporting requirements that call for independent certification or attestation. Under this model, the third party would evaluate whether the MA organization’s analysis was conducted in accordance with CMS requirements and that the reported results reasonably reflect the underlying provider directory information.

 

See where your provider data stands against the REAL Act, Medicare Plan Finder, and existing CMS requirements. Get the toolkit to understand your process and see if you’re on target. 

Free Provider Data Accuracy Audit Toolkit for Medicare Advantage Organizations

Public Accuracy Scores

What the statute requires: Beginning with contract years beginning on or after January 1, 2029, CMS will post provider directory accuracy scores in a machine-readable file on a CMS-maintained website. Each plan must list its score prominently in its directory.

What CMS proposes: The first set of public scores would come from contract year 2028, with plans reporting their scores by April 2029.

CMS is considering: Beyond the machine-readable file, CMS is exploring additional ways to share accuracy scores. Options include making scores available through CMS Application Programming Interfaces (APIs) and publishing them on the Medicare Plan Finder (MPF) website.

 

Enrollee Cost Sharing Protections

What the statute requires: Beginning with contract year 2028, an enrollee who relies on a directory listing for a provider who turns out to be out of network pays no more than the lesser of the in-network or otherwise applicable cost sharing. Plans must also notify enrollees of the protections, to the extent practicable by the first day of the annual coordinated election period, and include information about them in the provider directory.

What CMS Proposes: Enrollees can request protections verbally or in writing, and MA organizations would need to inform enrollees and evaluate claims automatically when they know or suspect protections apply. To verify eligibility, MA organizations would confirm the appointment date (using scheduling records, confirmations, or provider attestations) and whether the provider was listed as in-network on that date (using archived directory data). Provider contracts would need to include documentation requirements that survive termination for at least 10 years, and directory archives would need to be retained for the same period. When documentation is unavailable, protections default in the enrollee’s favor unless the MA organization can demonstrate they don’t apply. If an enrollee overpaid, the MA organization would refund the difference and count the cost sharing toward the in-network MOOP limit.

What CMS is considering: CMS is seeking comments on whether enrollees using physical hardcopy directories qualify for the same protections, the appropriateness of 10-year data retention requirements, whether MA organizations need to publicly post daily directory archives, and standardized formatting requirements for archived data.

 

Alternatives CMS is Actively Considering

CMS is considering several other aspects of the sampling framework and method, including the following.

  1. The overall framework for sample composition and size
  2. Whether to set specific dates for drawing the sample
  3. How provider non-responses should be handled in sampling and verification
  4. Whether data sources maintained by CMS, such as the National Provider Directory, should count toward the score
  5. Alternative scoring methodologies
  6. Whether low-enrollment plans should be exempt from the analysis

 

How to Comment

Comments must be received by 5 p.m. EST on Dec. 15, 2026, and should reference file code CMS-4214-P. They can be submitted in one of three ways: electronically at regulations.gov under docket CMS-2026-2533, by regular mail, or by express or overnight mail. CMS asks commenters to choose only one method and does not accept comments by fax.

The summary above reflects the statute and the proposed rule as published Oct. 20, 2026, and is not legal advice. Provisions may change in the final rule.

Quest Enterprise Services® for Medicare Advantage Organizations

As these regulations evolve, the administrative and operational requirements MA organizations must meet keep expanding as well. Quest Enterprise Services® (QES®) for Medicare Advantage is here to help you meet the REAL Act, Medicare Plan Finder, and existing CMS requirements covered here with QES® Accuracy, our solution to enhance your process, improve data transparency, reduce ghost networks, and strengthen compliance. Have questions? Reach out to us today and let our experts guide you. 

Proven Solutions for Your Provider Network Management

Looking to simplify your workload? Let Quest Analytics® take on the heavy lifting! Our solutions and dedicated team specialize in provider data accuracy and provider network adequacy for various lines of businesses, including Medicare Advantage, Medicaid and Commercial. Schedule a strategy session today and see how we can help you every step of the way.

Start a Conversation Today!